Confessions Of A Coldplay Convert

Posted Tue Jul 1, 2008 5:33pm PDT by David Marchese in The Spin Blog

Move in certain circles and you’re bound to hear plenty of griping about arena rock shows. Move in my circle and you may have even heard it from me. The stage is too far away, the tickets are too expensive, the beer only comes in little plastic cups. Up until a week ago, I’d pretty much sworn off large-scale concerts. But I’ve had a change of heart. Actually, I've had two.

The thing that changed my mind about massive shows was itself something I’d been ambivalent about: Coldplay. SPIN’s current coverboys had a handful of songs I dug--"Yellow," "Clocks," "Fix You"--but I was basically simpatico with people who saw the band as Radiohead lite. Then I saw Chris Martin and Co. play last Monday at Madison Square Garden in New York. That's when I realized that what I'd thought were the band's weaknesses were actually its strengths. Neon choruses, lyrics you don't need a Ph.D. to parse, Chris Martin's crooning. These things get better the bigger they are. What might come across as obvious or simplistic on record becomes elemental, even moving, in person. And I wasn't just bowing to peer pressure. (Even 10,000-strong, Coldplay fans aren't the most intimidating bunch.) Hearing anthems like "In My Place" or stompers like "Violet Hill" let loose in an arena was like seeing Big Brown bust out of the starting gate. The band’s songs--so epic, so big-hearted--need a huge room to reach their full potential. I get it now.

Coldplay wasn’t the first band that’s made me into a flip-flopper. Same thing happened with Pearl Jam. Sure, "Alive" kicked butt, but for a long time I lumped them in with STP, Soundgarden, and Alice In Chains--all the successful grunge bands that weren’t Nirvana. Then, in 2000, I saw them play. Yowza!

It’s funny when you finally get a band. You hear the old records differently. You’re willing to overlook their flaws. Their fans get way less annoying. Suddenly, it all makes sense. It's like being born again--but with way better music.

I know I'm not the only who’s had a band epiphany. Which bands have dragged you out of the darkness and into their light? But let's keep the discussion away from jam bands. We all know that’s just the drugs talking. 

105 Comments

1. nadwoa83 -
who's dating a girl there?

2. Adam S -
Defnitely Skillet... its a christian rock band that lends more towards the harder end of the scale, and while they had a couple good singles I didn't really dig them until I caught my first concert with them- What a Show!! Super energy, crazy crowd, and enough bass throws (swinging around the singers kneck like an instrument possesed) to satisfy your deepest pleasures. I know what you're saying with Coldplay too. Their singles were really good, Clocks had probably the greatest piano part of all time, or at least the most memorable, but I never really like the fact that the albums were all slower songs. Saw them live, it was like wow. Really love the new album too. I was so happy when I first heard the heavy guitars in Violet Hill. I was like, "Its not nerdy to be a Coldplay fan anymore!!!"

3. Bell Curve -
Sleepytime Gorilla Museum is definitely a band that you need to see live to fully appreciate. They might be the best live band I've ever seen.

4. Bell Curve -
Sleepytime Gorilla Museum is a band that has to be seen live to be fully appreciated. I've seen them 6 or 7 times and each show is better than the last.

5. JT S -
" I am trying to figure out when Coldplay became an "arena rock" band...just because you can play an arena does not make one an arena rock band...:

LOL!!! AMEN.

Arena rock includes actual musical talent, with good guitar solos. Boston? Journey? Styx?

NOT Coldplay.

6. Yahoo! Music User -
None of these bands are arena bands, not like motley crue, poison, bon jovi or other big 80`s acts. These bands like coldplay, and whoever is sleepy time gorillas( i bet they don`t play to 20,000 a night!)and will not be around for 20 years plus!!!!!

7. Klara T -
Funny, I feel the opposite about Coldplay - liked them before, but as time goes by I've found Chris Martin and his voice supremely annoying, and their music too desperate and try-hard without successfully capturing my interest. Since they're selling right now it's inconsequential what I think, but I feel eventually they'll drop off into some type of anonymity and be most remembered for their albums before X & Y, when they weren't sounding as pretentious or egotistical.
But hey, just my opinion!

8. JACK -
Rolling Stones...The kings of Arena Rock!

9. Dawn C -
Believe it or not for me it was Hanson. Yes. Mmmbop. Trust me I shared your distain. I was in college when they hit big and determined to hate them because of the hooplah. Then a couple of years ago I stumbled upon one of the singles off their first independent album, Underneath, and realized that they were pretty much what music was missing. A band that understood that you could rock and still write pop music.

10. Chris S -
Sevendust, Deftones, Nonpoint, Tool, Megadeth, all fine example of arena rock.
Coldplay not an arena rock band, dont get me wrong the musicianship is good..but seriously It makes me wanna sleep.

11. Bren -
LMAO Journey? Styx?
You have to be the biggest nerd.

Let's see...could any of them fill an arena today? lmao, lmao...

12. Bren -
a lot of Coldplay haters here...

you will be eating your words in about 10 years.

13. Sed P -
Coldplay is one of the most fitting monikers in pop history. Much as a "firefighter" is one who fights fires, "coldplay" is playing out their cold, lifeless songs on every available medium. From TV commercials to internet advertising, this rotten piece of british pop garbage is practically being forced down the consumers' throats.

No pop band should ever be considered rock. Likewise, arena rock should not be called a genre, so much as it should be called a point in an artist career when their music has become so watered down that it is commercially viable.


It's unfortunate really.

14. teacher_man1067 -
My first rock concert was 1979; STYX at the Veteran's Memorial Coliseum in Phoenix. Had to be over 25,000 there. I've seen them three times since, including this past weekend in Tucson (minus Dennis DeYoung) along with Boston, and maybe 20 other rock bands in between. The only one that comes close to the experience I had in '79 was my first Jimmy Buffet concert three years ago. His fans are nuts.

15. Scootin_z 1 -
oh and before Bren makes a comment...It was a PACKED house. 24,000 saw that show...and over 100,000 last time those boys played Rio. They own when it comes to "musicianship"
HANDS DOWN...

And last time I saw Styx on their reunion tour...they definately sold some seats as well. Most of those bands draw quire well. Nerd? Styx has some killer old cuts. You might want to dig...before you dish it out. My guess is most of this music is older than you...

16. teacher_man1067 -
Get a grip, Bren. Read the prompt; it isn't about filling arenas NOW. It's about "best arena rock bands"; no time limits applied. Nerd.

17. andrew h -
Some arena rock bands from 30 years ago are still selling out arenas today. Kiss, Van Halen, Rolling Stones, AC/DC, Eagles, etc. Some bands have one successful tour that fills arenas then their fan base slow evaporates. The true test is longevity. No recent bands last very long and definetly can't compete with the forementioned bands.

18. Jeremy S -
There needs to be a distinction here between arena rock (bands that turn out track after track that just begs to be song along to by then entire crowd - Motley Crue, Poison, Bon Jovi, i.e.) and an arena show which most bands attempt these days but few succeed in actually pulling off the right way. In terms of arena rock, I feel like it's making a small comeback with bands like Three Days Grace, songs like I Hate Everything About You are a step in the right direction. In terms of an arena show, the best I've seen include Tool - by far the best show I've seen, Switchfoot - incredibly moving, and TobyMac - more energetic than any group out there. Again, the distinction must be made between arena rock and an arena show, Coldplay puts on an arena show, in my opinion.

19. whitspirit77 -
I've liked Coldplay since the release of their 1st record Parachutes. I waited and bought ROBTTH in the fall of 2002 - powerful. Time passed and less than 6 months later I saw them in the Civic Center in OKC. It was a small, intimate group, sold out - and before they sold out major stadiums. Everyone there knew each song by heart, including me. Coldplay is unique with passion and heart that most bands cannot match. I stand by Coldplay and am proud of their growth and evolvement. Viva la Vida is fantastic. Go Coldplay!

20. Pallavi P -
sed_p

how dare you say they're rotten garbage.
control your words okay.

sure you're free to say everything.but it doesn't mean that you can type what ever bullsh**T that comes to you.

Coldplay is the biggest band in the world,and will also continue,its the most awesome band ever,and as they're there this world is really looking awesome to me.
Page:  1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 
Next »
Leave Your Comment
You must sign in to leave a comment
Select a Blog Posts
And The Winner Is...
by Lyndsey Parker
12
As Heard On...
by Suzanne Baran
11
Better Living Through MP3
by Ken Micallef
141
Chart Watch
by Paul Grein
47
Framed
by John Kordosh
56
GetBack
by Shawn Amos
65
Hip-Hop Media Training
by Billy Johnson, Jr.
42
List Of The Day
by Rob O'Connor
229
Maximum Performance
by Suzanne Baran
76
New This Week
by Dave DiMartino
59
On the Road With JamBase
by Aaron Kayce
23
Reality Rocks
by Lyndsey Parker
245
Rock's Backpages
by Keith Altham
69
Rolling Stone Song Of The Day
by Chuck Eddy
48
Stop The Presses!
by Billy Altman
8
That's Really Week
by Lyndsey Parker
63
The ARTHUR Blog
by Paul Krassner
36
The Blender Burner
by Blender Magazine
1
The Lefsetz Letter
by Bob Lefsetz
188
The MOJO Blog
by Lois Wilson
40
The NME Blog
by Dan Martin
21
The Spin Blog
by David Marchese
21
The URB Blog
by Brandon Perkins
9
The Y! Music Playlist Blog
by Robert of the Radish
280
Video Ga Ga
by Lyndsey Parker
34

Music Blog Archives

September 2008 (1)
August 2008 (4)
July 2008 (5)
June 2008 (2)
May 2008 (1)
March 2008 (1)
January 2008 (3)
December 2007 (2)
November 2007 (2)
Lindsay and Samantha rock the runway crowd
AP
Sat Sep 6, 2008 2:10pm PDT
AP - Nobody draws attention like Lindsay Lohan and gal pal Samantha Ronson. The duo sat in the front row for the Saturday morning presentation of Ronson's sister Charlotte's spring collection at New York Fashion Week,…
More »
More Music News
My Music


Create your very own radio station based on your music tastes.