Idol Elimination Night: Carry On, Wayward Amanda

Posted Wed Mar 19, 2008 7:09pm PDT by Lyndsey Parker in Reality Rocks

Listen closely, kids. Hear that? That's the sound of John Lennon and George Harrison rolling in their respective graves.

Seriously, from Amanda inexplicably getting to sing the big "love you make" hook, to the Broadway-style line-formation singalong of the Abbey Road acid-casualty epic "Because," to the awkward moment when Ramiele's mic seemed to be turned off, to David Archuleta ironically singing "While My Guitar Gently Weeps" so soon after his stage dad allegedly made him weep...well, tonight's opening Beatles medley had me and probably the rest of America crying out for "Help!"

Enough with the Beatles songs already, OK? Surely by now Nigel Lythgoe must realize that doing a second Fab Four Week wasn't such a fab idea. It's downright tragic to think that uninitiated youngsters unfamiliar with the Beatles may now forever associate this great band's music with travesties like this. So let's hope tonight is the last Beatlesque Idol episode for a while. And let's pray there's no Wings Night, no Traveling Wilburys night, and no Plastic Ono Band Night, either. And for the love of gawd, if Idol does a Ringo Starr Solo Night, I'll never watch this dang show again!

Oh, and it wasn't enough for tonight's show to wreck the Beatles' legacy--it had to ruin a perfectly good Clash song, too, in that Ford promo. Whoever came up with THAT idea is the real person who should've been eliminated tonight. Hear that distinctive rustle in the background? That's the sound of Joe Strummer rolling in his grave as well.

OK, OK, enough of my kvetching. There were some things to cheer about tonight--like the sassy performance by a suspiciously less busty Kellie Pickler, or the fact that my favorite contestants (Brooke White, David Cook, and Jason Castro, and thin-ice-skating Michael Johns) all made it through. True, none of them gave their best performances last night, but none of them deserved to go home just yet. I'm just so relieved that they've made the top 10, as they're now guaranteed a spot on this season's upcoming Idol tour and compilation album! In the words of Danny Noriega...Score!

And another really, really good thing happened tonight: The rock 'n' roll nurse got cut. I would've been even happier if bullet-dodging Kristy Lee Cook, who was also quite justifiably in the bottom two this week, had finally gotten the boot. But hey, Amanda Overmyer simply had to go. And better her than Carly Smithson, who was surprisingly in the bottom three tonight. (Carly's not my fave, but if she'd failed to make the top 10, Randy Jackson might've had a coronary--and that would have been bad, dawg.)

Anyway, good luck, Amanda. Good luck pursuing your fantasy of selling out a local bar in Lafayette. Dare to dream!

The burning question now is, with Danny and Amanda gone, who will Vote For The Worst endorse next? Watch this space...

 

For more American Idol, go to Yahoo! TV

2568 Comments

1. Yahoo! Music User -
Dearest LP, your readers are one smart bunch. If you check old posts, some predict Carly as being a surprise Bottom 3.

As for this posting, I love this latest blog.
And thank you for posting it so soon, because I was dying to know what your thoughts are as the show unfolded. I bet you'll get tons of relevant and intelligent responses as usual.

You have to get a few guest bloggers because you've got some dedicated fans, like Joe T., Nate, Rain C, hunter, Greg Y., jsandzjamzz, and so many others who are nameless (and have usernames but I can't recall perfectly).

Such bloggers are a real credit to you. Thanks for all your hard work. I think you posted 7 blogs in 2 days. Whoa!!! Thank you.

All the best...

2. Yahoo! Music User -
"Listen closely, kids. Hear that?" ~ LP.

I heard it too LP! LOL.

3. Yahoo! Music User -
Yep, I admit it I have a huge crush on Nigel Lythgoe, but even I have to admit he keeps flubbing it this season. First his response about semi-pros (Elvis?) and now, a second week of The Beatles. Yep, he "must realize that doing a second Fab Four Week wasn't such a fab idea."

4. Yahoo! Music User -
Paul McCartney has already had a tough enough week with the Heather Mills divorce. Why put him through this torture too? I agree - no more Beatles songs this season please.

5. Yahoo! Music User -
"The burning question now is, with Danny and Amanda gone, who will Vote For The Worst endorse next?" I think it will be Kristy! (Sorry to her fans as I think arrangements have done her in, rather than her vocals).

6. Yahoo! Music User -
Hi LP , from about #340 onwards, the posts on the blog about Tuesday were written during or after tonight's episode. Don't want you to miss those. *wink* Thank you for posting 6 or more blogs in the past two days by the way. A lot of us notice how hard you work; a lot of us appreciate it. I also add my voice to the chorus re: a guest blogger. You have such a great little community here, it would be just like you to do something like that and you have tons of people to choose from. The toughest part is who to choose, because there are more than a few who are deserving. Also, what do you think of a blank blog for comments during the show? *wink* *wink* Luv ya...

7. Yahoo! Music User -
at least amanda was entertaining and wasn't afraid to be herself. you can't say the same for everyone else.

"idol" tour is a joke anyway. they couldn't sell tickets last season, and this season won't be any different.

8. Yahoo! Music User -
That's funny! 5. Yahoo! Music User!

9. kim b -
it was a mistake to let ammanda go.
that girl has a voice

10. Yahoo! Music User -
at least this proves votefortheworst doesn't have that much power. their 2 picks got cut kinda early on. danny didn't make the top 12 and amaznda didn't make the top 10.

11. Yahoo! Music User -
Amanda Overmyer sang "Back in the U.S.S.R." and fittingly she's now headed home. Carly seemed genuinely upset to see her roommate get the axe. But then again, if I was a talented vocalist in that competition I'd cry too when Amanda left because as long as she was there, I'd feel a little more safe. LOL.

12. Donald I -
i just found out there more female
voters than male

13. Yahoo! Music User -
I know I'm probably alone, or in a very small crowd, but I'll miss the streaked hair Amanda and her flair(?) for southern rock. It's all about the hair man. Shaggy (David Cook)! Dreadlocked (Jason Castro)!

14. Yahoo! Music User -
Musical wallpaper must be more appealing to voters than streaked hair.

15. Mary M -
I am glad Amanda went home as I think she sounded the same week after week and was not that good. However, I also was glad to see Carly in the bottom 3. The judges rave too much about her and she's not that great especially when she sings high notes...OUCH.
I hope she goes soon!

Glad to see Kristy got another chance...hopefully she will pick better songs because she has a good voice.

16. Yahoo! Music User -
How was it reported that Amanda was off when I am still watching AI (LIVE) and they haven't given the final ax?

17. byebyecarbs2003 -
Kristy is simply Sanjaya with boobs! No talent and yet...they keep going and going in the competition while people with MORE TALENT leave!

18. Yahoo! Music User -
Now Kristy, if you can "blow [Simon] out of [his] socks" make sure he knows it. I have two words for you: Leona Lewis!

19. Yahoo! Music User -
what the buzz with that Castro guy. On par performer. Better have shows at high schools.

20. Kathy -
Carly has to go next....the tattoo grosses me out and she has absolutely no personality!
Page:  1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 
Next »
Leave Your Comment
You must sign in to leave a comment
Select a Blog Posts
And The Winner Is...
Wendy Geller
11
As Heard On...
Suzanne Baran
6
Better Living Through MP3
Ken Micallef
123
Chart Watch
Paul Grein
36
Framed
John Kordosh
47
GetBack
Cory Frye
18
Hip-Hop Media Training
Billy Johnson, Jr.
33
List Of The Day
Rob O'Connor
212
Maximum Performance
Lyndsey Parker
60
New This Week
Dave DiMartino
51
On the Road With JamBase
Aaron Kayce
20
Reality Rocks
Lyndsey Parker
189
Rock's Backpages
Barney Hoskyns
50
Rolling Stone Song Of The Day
Rolling Stone
4
That's Really Week
Lyndsey Parker
54
The ARTHUR Blog
Paul Krassner
31
The Lefsetz Letter
Bob Lefsetz
142
The MOJO Blog
Kris Needs
39
The NME Blog
Dan Martin
19
The Spin Blog
David Marchese
12
The URB Blog
Brandon Perkins
9
The Y! Music Playlist Blog
Robert of the Radish
240
Video Ga Ga
Wendy Geller
15

Music Blog Archives

July 2008 (3)
June 2008 (30)
May 2008 (27)
April 2008 (28)
March 2008 (31)
February 2008 (21)
January 2008 (12)
December 2007 (4)
November 2007 (4)
October 2007 (5)
September 2007 (4)
August 2007 (2)
July 2007 (13)
June 2007 (4)
May 2007 (1)
Winehouse sings in Spain, glass of wine in hand
AP
Sat Jul 5, 2008 6:11pm PDT
AP - Soul diva Amy Winehouse sipped from a glass of red wine and looked a bit unsteady on her feet as she appeared in front of a large audience at the Rock in Rio music festival southeast of Madrid on Friday. Then, as…
More »
More Music News
My Music


Create your very own radio station based on your music tastes.