American Idol: When Self-Esteem Is Not Enough

Posted Tue Jan 15, 2008 11:15pm PST by Lyndsey Parker in Reality Rocks

All right, American Idol: The Search For The Next Sanjaya started up this week, and though I could just write up the usual episode recap, I've decided to instead use this cyber-soapbox to get something off my chest. Something that needs to be said by someone other than Simon Cowell.

OK, here goes: We live in the era of too much self-esteem. See, for decades, various child psychologists, self-help gurus, well-meaning Learning Annex instructors, Dr. Phil, et al have cited low self-esteem as the root cause of all societal ills. "No one can love you until you love yourself," these American-dream-weavers boldly decreed. "You can do anything you set your mind to," they optimistically promised. "Nothing is impossible as long as you believe in yourself."

Well, after viewing the season 7 Idol premiere, I am here to say that this self-esteem stuff is a load of bunk.

It's this sort of thinking that's spawned a generation of Paris Hilton-worshipping, Bratz-emulating tweens who feel the need to advertise their imagined superiority by wearing T-shirts inappropriately emblazoned with words like "Hottie" and "Princess" and "Diva." And it's precisely this sort of thinking that's bred a nation of tone-deaf wannabes with inflated senses of entitlement and unwavering conviction that they're more talented than all four Beatles combined...all of 'em caterwauling Whitney Houston's "Greatest Love Of All" at American Idol auditions and taking the lyrics way too seriously.

Yep, this is because no one--not until Simon and Randy came along, at least--ever dared crush these kids' "self-esteem" by telling them the truth: that sometimes believing in yourself and never giving up simply is not enough. That sometimes giving up and moving on to Plan B is actually a pretty good idea, IF YOU CANNOT SING. And that sometimes, just sometimes, maybe you can love yourself just a wee bit too much.

This season, one of the Idol hopefuls, nine-months-pregnant Antoria Gillon, went into labor while waiting for her chance to sing. Naturally, she didn't let a little nuisance like contractions stop her from completing her (initially successful) audition, but eventually she was rushed off to the hospital to give birth to a bouncing baby boy that she christened Jamil Labarron Idol McCowan. (Yes, "Idol" is the child's middle name, right there on the birth certificate.) Now, congratulations are of course in order for Antoria and the first official Baby Idol. But I do hope that if little Jamil grows up with aspirations to be a singer like his mama--but he sounds like William Hung on a bad day--that Antoria will sit him down and, in a compassionately Paula Abdul-ish yet firm manner, let him know that music just ain't his forte. He'll appreciate her tough love later.

OK, do come back tomorrow for a more straight-ahead recap of night #2 of this week's double-whammy American Idol kickoff. I just felt this message needed to be conveyed, as some sort of public service. Because maybe if a few stage-parents of the next generation of Sanjayas read this, they won't squander thousands of dollars on singing lessons and cross-country Greyhound tickets to the American Idol season 20 auditions, just because they're afraid of wounding their untalented offspring's precious pride. 

Thanks for hearing me out...

5 Comments

1. Creegirl -
Idol?!?!?!? She named that kid Idol.... LOL LMAO LOL LMFAO........... Ok that's just sad! LOL

2. Joan R -
Thank you very much! At least somebody was on the same side as I am. I love watching the premier for laughs, these people are funny and they have GUTS!!! LOL ... although I have to cover my ears most of the time :-)

3. fiondel -
Oh...now ....STOP! If you TELL them they can't sing before they audition, then how will we get a chance to laugh at them? You're just a fun ruiner, that's what YOU are! :)

4. A Yahoo! User -
i love american idol. it is entertaining and well edited. everything in our culture is creating delusional people. people that think they are relevant on myspace or facebook. people that take a phone call while a grocery store clerk is trying to help them. people that are good at texting. every schmuck that gives themselves some lame hip hop name (mine way be "a-slave" yo!) it takes no creativity to get a username and account on myspace. it takes no creativity to sing on american idol.

if sanjaya was a fake....great! it was entertaining. if they get exploited and develop eating disorders and drug habits.....great...we are overpopulated anyway.

if everything on reality TV is fake....who cares? what is disturbing are people that saturate their lives with this stuff and feel like they know these people or want to be one of them.

it's like that dude that wrote "a million little pieces" and went on oprah. oprah was all mad and said she was duped by him. why do i care if a single word of what that schmo wrote was real or not. as long as it is entertaining i don't care. if it would have made his book better to create a homosexual relationship with his football coach then go ahead!

individuals out to make a buck off their life story are not relevant to me. i pay attentions when it entertains and hope for some tragic eating disorders and drug dependencies here and there.

as long as you don't fake the stuff that matters and revise my history books....go for it, but not much in our world these days is socially relevant.

does anyone really think that katie holmes or christian bales story to a late night host about their traditional holiday dinner with ma and pa is real? it's not....they are selling themselves.

keep on buying america!

5. Lyndsey Parker -
It is true, the bad auditions are the most fun part of Idol. I watch with delight. But we the viewers laughing AT these people, not WITH them, and I don't think a lot of these auditioners realize how foolish they seem. Their level of delusion scares me! They really think they can sing!
Leave Your Comment
You must sign in to leave a comment
Select a Blog Posts
And The Winner Is...
by Lyndsey Parker
14
As Heard On...
by Suzanne Baran
12
Better Living Through MP3
by Ken Micallef
148
Chart Watch
by Paul Grein
53
Framed
by John Kordosh
60
GetBack
by Shawn Amos
84
Hip-Hop Media Training
by Billy Johnson, Jr.
52
List Of The Day
by Rob O'Connor
237
Maximum Performance
by Lyndsey Parker
81
New This Week
by Dave DiMartino
64
On the Road With JamBase
by Aaron Kayce
24
Reality Rocks
by Lyndsey Parker
260
Rock's Backpages
by Mitchell Cohen (1976)
77
Rolling Stone Song Of The Day
by Chuck Eddy
70
Stop The Presses!
by Billy Altman
19
That's Really Week
by Dave DiMartino
67
The ARTHUR Blog
by Jay Babcock
41
The Blender Burner
by Blender Magazine
5
The Lefsetz Letter
by Bob Lefsetz
211
The MOJO Blog
by Stevie Chick
41
The NME Blog
by Dan Martin
22
The Spin Blog
by David Marchese
26
The URB Blog
by Brandon Perkins
9
The Y! Music Playlist Blog
by Robert of the Radish
298
Video Ga Ga
by Lyndsey Parker
40

Music Blog Archives

October 2008 (1)
September 2008 (15)
August 2008 (28)
July 2008 (31)
June 2008 (30)
May 2008 (27)
April 2008 (27)
March 2008 (31)
February 2008 (21)
January 2008 (12)
December 2007 (4)
November 2007 (4)
October 2007 (5)
September 2007 (4)
August 2007 (2)
July 2007 (13)
June 2007 (4)
May 2007 (1)
A rejuvenated Maxwell returns after 7-year break
AP
Tue Oct 7, 2008 3:00pm PDT
AP - It's hardly unusual for a singer to drop off the musical map. Declining album sales, drug habits, legal woes and other dramas have landed a multitude of chart-toppers on the "Whatever Happened To ..."…
More »
More Music News
My Music


Create your very own radio station based on your music tastes.