Week Ending May 11, 2008: Diamond Tops Dylan As Oldest Living Chart-Topper

Posted Wed May 14, 2008 11:28am PDT by Paul Grein in Chart Watch

Neil Diamond this week becomes the oldest living artist to land a #1 album in the 52-year history of Billboard's weekly album chart. Diamond, 67, achieves the feat with Home Before Dark. The old record was held by Bob Dylan, who was 65 when he last topped the chart in September 2006 with Modern Times.

Only two other solo artists have had #1 albums past the age of 60--Louis Armstrong, who was 62 in 1964 when he topped the chart with Hello, Dolly! and Rod Stewart, who was 61 in 2006 when he rang the bell with Still The Same...Great Rock Classics Of Our Time.

Key group members who had #1 albums past the age of 60 are Ronald Isley, who was 62 in 2003 when the Isley Brothers' Body Kiss topped the chart; Ringo Starr, who was 60 in 2000 when the Beatles' 1 hit #1; and Don Henley, Joe Walsh and Timothy B. Schmidt, all of whom were 60 last fall when Eagles' Long Road Out Of Eden hit #1.

I know what you're thinking: How about those old-timers who had #1 albums in the early years of the rock era? Surely they were over 60 at the time. Surprisingly, except for Armstrong, they weren't. (People just seemed older back then.) Lawrence Welk was 58 in 1961 when he hit #1 with Calcutta!, Bing Crosby and conductor Enoch Light were both 54 when they landed their last #1 albums, conductor Mantovani was 53 and "Sing Along With Mitch" creator Mitch Miller was 50.

(Two pop legends were older than Diamond when they recorded their final albums, but the albums weren't released until after their deaths. Ray Charles' Genius Loves Company hit #1 in 2005, eight months after the R&B legend died at 73. Johnny Cash's American V: A Hundred Highways hit #1 in 2006, nearly three years after the country giant died at 71.)

(Two other legends who were older than Diamond is now just missed hitting #1 with late-career releases. Frank Sinatra was 77 in 1993 when Duets peaked at #2; Tony Bennett was 80 in 2006 when Duets: An American Classic peaked at #3.)

There is no question that the pop scene is more receptive to older artists than it used to be. From 1966, when Sinatra, then 50, landed his last #1 album, Strangers In The Night, until 1993, when Barbra Streisand, then 51, scored with Back To Broadway, not one artist over the age of 50 topped the chart. But in the last 15 years, it's become commonplace. No one thought twice about it in April when George Strait, 55, hit #1. After all, just last fall, in addition to the aforementioned Eagles, Bruce Springsteen, 58, and Reba McEntire, 52, had #1 albums. In the last five years, we've also seen #1 albums by Barry Manilow, who was 59 at the time, Jimmy Buffett, 57, and Led Zeppelin, whose members ranged from mid to late 50s.

What's going on here? The baby boomer audience is staying connected to the pop scene much longer than their parents ever did. Also, older fans are proving to be the most reliable album buyers. They came of age buying albums and are perfectly content to continue. What's more, if these older fans download an album (Nielsen/SoundScan includes paid downloads in its tallies), they are more inclined to pay than go to a file-sharing site.

I'm not sure how Diamond will react to being called "the oldest living chart-topper." But let's break it down. Certainly, it's good to be living. It's a nice bonus to be a chart-topper. As for being the oldest, well, as they say, it beats the alternative. So take it, Neil, and run with it.

Diamond lands his first #1 album nearly 42 years after he first entered the chart with The Feel Of Neil Diamond. That sets a new record for the longest any artist has had to wait for his or her first #1 album. The old record belonged to Jimmy Buffett, who took a little more than 30 years between first entering the chart in March 1974 and landing his first #1 album, License To Chill, in July 2004.

Diamond's highest-charting album before this week was the soundtrack to Jonathan Livingston Seagull, which reached #2 in 1973. That album also brought Diamond his only Grammy Award to date, for Best Album of Original Score. If you stopped people on the street, most would assume that Diamond has had numerous #1 albums and has won a shelf-full of Grammys. Why he hasn't, I don't know. But maybe that's one reason he has lasted so long: He has never been so white-hot that people got sick of him.

Home Before Dark is Diamond's second collaboration with Grammy-winning producer Rick Rubin, following 12 Songs, which opened (and peaked) at #4 in November 2005. Rubin also produced a series of five late-career albums for Johnny Cash, which culminated in the aforementioned chart-topper American V: A Hundred Highways.

Rihanna, 20, also makes news this week, opening at #1 on Hot Digital Songs with "Take A Bow." Rihanna is the first artist to top this chart four times. She previously led the list with "Pon De Replay," "SOS" and "Umbrella." "Take A Bow" opens with sales of 267,000 downloads. Only two songs have sold that many downloads in their first week. Mariah Carey's "Touch My Body" sold 286,000 and Rihanna's own "Umbrella," featuring Jay-Z, moved 277,000. Ne-Yo, Rihanna's duet partner on the recent "Hate That I Love You," wrote "Take A Bow." This is the eighth consecutive week that the #1 title on the Hot Digital Songs chart has sold 200,000 or more downloads.

Here's the low-down on this week's top 10 albums.

1. Neil Diamond, Home Before Dark, 146,000. This album is off to a faster start than the first Diamond/Rubin collaboration, 12 Songs, which sold 93,000 copies in its first week. (Maybe it pays to actually come up with a title!) Diamond had 13 top 10 singles on the Hot 100 from the ‘60s into the ‘80s, but none of them were from #1 albums. Now, he finally has a #1 album without help from a hit single. Go figure.

2. Toby Keith, 35 Biggest Hits, 103,000. This two-CD set is the latest greatest hits album to tout the number of hits right in the title, the better to position the album as a good value for the money. It follows Elvis Presley's Elv1s: 30 #1 Hits and George Strait's 50 Greatest Hits. Both of those collections reached #1. (George's hit count is largest, so he wins.) The album includes Keith's new hit, "She's A Hottie," which jumps from #115 to #79 on Hot Digital Songs.

3. Madonna, Hard Candy, 94,000. Sales of the album dropped by 66%, the steepest decline of any album in the top 200. Hard Candy had just one week at #1, which has been the case with all four of Madonna's #1 albums in this decade. Her three #1 albums from the ‘80s all had extended stays in the top spot. Like A Virgin was #1 for three weeks, True Blue for five and Like A Prayer for six. "4 Minutes," Madonna's smash collabo with Justin Timberlake, slips from #3 to #5; "Give It 2 Me" falls from #21 to #74.

4. Clay Aiken, On My Way Here, 94,000. Aiken's solo debut, Measure Of A Man, debuted at #1 with sales of 613,000. His collection of pop covers, A Thousand Different Ways, opened at #2 with sales of 211,000. This third release (not counting a holiday album) continues the downward trend. Unlike most recording stars whose numbers are softening, Aiken has Broadway and TV to fall back on.

5. Mariah Carey, E=MC2, 87,000. Carey drops from #2 to #4 in her fourth week. "Touch My Body" drifts from #11 to #14 on Hot Digital Songs. "Bye Bye" regains some ground, jumping from #41 to #36.

6. Leona Lewis, Spirit, 76,000. Sales of Lewis' album now stand at 555,000, making it the eighth best seller so far in 2008. "Bleeding Love" slips to #2 on Hot Digital Songs after four weeks on top; "Better In Time" drops from #87 to #120.

7. Gavin DeGraw, Gavin DeGraw, 66,000. DeGraw's sophomore album puts him in the top 10 for the first time.  The adult alternative artist debuted in 2003 with Chariot, which was reissued as a two-CD set the following year. "In Love With A Girl" jumps from #19 to #15 on Hot Digital Songs; "We Belong Together" bows at #122.

8. Josh Groban, Awake Live, 58,000. Groban's first release since walking off with the #1 album of 2007 (Noel) is a live revisiting of the songs on his most recent pop album, Awake (which re-enters the chart this week at #87). Groban has released a live album after each of his three pop studio albums, a strategy that is known inside the industry as "milking it." This is the first of Groban's three live albums to reach the top 10.

9. Dierks Bentley, Greatest Hits/Every Mile A Memory 2003-2008, 43,000. This is Bentley's third album to crack the top 10, following Modern Day Drifter and Long Trip Alone. (Memo to Dierks: Amass a few dozen more hits, and then one-up George Strait with 51 Greatest Hits.) The album includes Dierks' newest hit, "Trying To Stop Your Leaving," which enters Hot Digital Songs at #111.

10. Luis Miguel's Complices, 32,000. This is the first top 10 album for the Latin superstar, who has been a fixture on the pop chart for 15 years. Miguel's previous highest charting album was Romances, which reached #14 in 1997. This is the first Latin album to reach the top 10 since Jennifer Lopez's Como Ama Una Mujer debuted at #10 in April 2007. Miguel was born in San Juan, Puerto Rico. J Lo was born in the Bronx to Puerto Rican parents.

Seven albums fall out of the top 10 this week. Lyfe Jennings' Lyfe Change slips from #4 to #12, Now 27 drops from #9 to #13, Tim McGraw's Greatest Hits 1 & 2 falls from #10 to #20, Portishead's Third drops from #7 to #24, The Roots' Rising Down drops from #6 to #28, Def Leppard's Songs From The Sparkle Lounge falls from #5 to #30 and Mudcrutch's Mudcrutch plummets from #8 to #53.

Two songs from Coldplay's upcoming album Viva La Vida Or Death And All His Friends (that's a mouthful) enter the Hot Digital Songs chart. "Viva La Vida" arrives at #6; "Violet Hill" opens at #18.

Market Indicator: Now 27 logged eight weeks in the top 10 before slipping this week to #13. Alas, only now, after nine weeks of release, has the album equaled the first-week sales (621,000) of the fastest-selling Now volume, Now 7. That album was released in 2001 when the industry was at its peak.

Rascal Flatts' Still Feels Good jumps from #78 to #37 with an 85% sales increase, the week's biggest for a non-debuting album. The album has sold 1,922,000 copies since it debuted at #1 in October.

I Can Only Imagine: Power Anthems Of The Christian Faith holds at #1 for a fourth week on the Catalog Albums chart, with sales of 17,000. The Time/Life collection would have ranked #37 on the big chart if older, catalog albums were eligible to compete there.

Ol Blue Eyes: Hard to believe, but it's been 10 years since Frank Sinatra died--on May 14, 1998. In addition to being a tremendous artist and an eternal icon of cool, Sinatra was one of the biggest recording stars of all time. Sinatra ranks as the #30 album seller of the Nielsen/SoundScan era, with sales of 25,804,000. The remarkable thing about this statistic is that it measures sales only since Nielsen/SoundScan set up shop in May 1991.

Sinatra first hit the Billboard album chart--which was not yet a weekly feature--in 1946 with The Voice Of Frank Sinatra. Only one other artist on Nielsen/SoundScan's list of the top 200 album sellers first entered the album chart prior to 1955. That's Nat "King" Cole, whose jazz trio was #1 on the very first album chart in 1945 with The King Cole Trio. Cole is the #185 album seller since 1991.

Sinatra has sold 14,872,000 albums in the 10 years since his death (a figure that many current artists would be quite content with.) That number will swell with the release this week of Nothing But The Best. The compilation is certain to become Sinatra's highest-charting posthumous album. That title is currently held by Greatest Love Songs. Released just before Valentine's Day 2002, the album peaked at #32.

Which of today's chart-toppers will still be relevant 60 years from now? Discuss amongst yourselves.

Heads Up: Death Cab For Cutie is expected to debut at #1 next week with Narrow Stairs. Other albums due to enter next week's chart include Jason Mraz's We Sing, We Dance, We Steal Things, Ryan Cabrera's The Moon Under Water, Keith Sweat's Just Me, Duffy's Rockferry and 10 Years' Division.

It's Here: My favorite song about May is "The Lusty Month Of May," from the 1960 Broadway musical, Camelot. The show was Lerner & Loewe's follow-up to My Fair Lady. Composer Frederick Loewe has many fans to this day, including rapper Flo Rida, who, on his recent smash, chanted, "Loewe, Loewe, Loewe, Loewe."

158 Comments

1. CK -
Now albums can reach number one even if they are not very good. The first week sales are all about the popularity of the artist and his marketing group's ability to promote the album instead of the quality of the album.

2. JNez -
i remember reading your chart beat columns in Billboard 20 years ago! What a great feeling to rediscover you still writing about Billboard in a new medium.

3. nylonpunk -
It doesn't seem like theirs any great artists on the list to me. I'll tip my hat to Madonna on her whole career, but she's so hung up on techno her stuff isn't "user friendly". Mudcrutch was number 8 last week? Mudcrutch? There is no depth to the talent these days. The labels are buying up little pseudo punk boy bands, and this weeks hip hop megastar will fade quickly...This is a crappy time to be a teenager finding yourself in music...Fall out boy's lame guitar player did a freakin wall mart ad. These poor kids today...

4. Scott K -
The charts have ALWAYS determined the popularity of an album based on sales. That fact has never changed. To say an album at the top isn't any good and only based on marketing, is really just pointing out that YOU don't agree or don't like the album or artist. I would definitely say that charts reflect broad based appeal and great marketing. The artistic merit is always arguable.

5. guido -
its good to see SINATRA is still around,love ya frank

6. esa209 -
Great blog; I love reading Chart Watch every week!!

7. Marti J -
I am sure his appearance on Idol helped.

8. Steve -
I saw Neil 20 some odd years ago in concert. Good to see him still doin' it and succeeding

9. Brian C -
Anybody know how old Cher was when she had her last #1?
BTW; Don't you sugar seekers have your own forum somewhere?

10. fab995 -
Mudcrutch's name may sound like a Limp Bizkit ripoff, but when you count Tom Petty and two of his Heartbreakers as members, i'd say that's pretty deep talent. Sadly, that seems to be the exception rather than the norm these days, so good on Neil Diamond for showing that talent, rather than solely marketing, can land you a number one album.

11. Erin R -
with all the over 65 artists hitting the no.1 mark it just goes to show the babyboomers are still buying music that they like,from music artists the boomers made famous in the first place.LONG LIVE THE PIG IN THE PYTHON GENERATION!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

12. Yahoo! Music User -
I pre ordered the CD and I wasn't disappointed. I've been a fan since the 1960's when he first recorded. This CD is a very different Neil Diamond. I like the new version but I love the old Neil Diamond.
The best to him for keeping us all entertained for all these years.
Brookly Rose

13. Tom J -
Paul Grein, you're neglecting one important factor in why Neil Diamond's album is number 1. Considering his pairing with producer Rick Rubin again, and that he's not turning out anthems where he's barking "TODAY!" younger people, like me (not a kid - I'm 35 - but I'm not his main audience) are simply interested in his strong songwriting skills. My parents, however, HATE the direction he's taken with these two albums. That audience appears to want those anthems. I would guess a great number of sales went to people in my age group, not to his traditional market.

Nylonpunk: Mudcrutch is Tom Petty and his previous band from 30 years ago. Very talented band.

14. nebulus43 -
It is absolutly rediculous that sales dictate an albums popularity. Lets be honest here, Who owns these albums?? Where are the albums that everyone cherrishes. Where are those key universal languages that surpass all stereotypes?! (i.e. Sublime and Bob Marley)

15. harvardscouch -
pull out the vinyl. and ditch the mp3 player!!!!

16. Victoria S -
Growing up in a household where my father loved Neil Diamond, I went in one of the two possible opinion directions...I cringe every time I hear his name. Regardless, I've gotta give the man props for still being out there, recording, and doing well. Talk about a devoted fanbase!

p.s. Dear everyone who feels the need to put up all of the matchmaking site spam nonsense. Stop. Now.

17. Victoria S -
Oh...and nebulus? I'll agree with the Bob Marley, but even half the stoners out there have to admit --- Sublime is vastly overrated.

18. Yahoo! Music User -
"Absolutely ridiculous that sales dictate an albums popularity," How ridiculous is that statment? This encompasses, by definition, what popularity is. How else would you measure popularity? Now if you're talking about artisitc merit, that's a different story altogether.

Regardless, I'm glad to see Neil Diamond finally get a #1 album. I was surprised to read that he's only won 1 Grammy. I think that should be rectified by giving him the Grammy for Lifetime Achievement.

19. rockyswc -
I bought my first Diamond album on 8-track. I grduated to real vinyl with "Brother Love's Travelin' Salvation Show." My parents thought "Hot August Night" was "Hard Rock". "Love at the Greek" showed me bnoth I and Niel had matured. Yes, Neil can still sing and it's not just marketing. Yes I'm dating myself but so will the youngsters I see writing here. I just wonder what they will remember in 30 or 40 years, (I still have my old vinyl)!!!

20. bluegarish -
Gosh i thiught that you'd have to sell alot more than 146,000 copies of an album to get to number one. I guess anyone can do it now a days! I seriously thught it had to be like at least half a million or something.
Page:  1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 
Next »
Leave Your Comment
You must sign in to leave a comment
Select a Blog Posts
And The Winner Is...
by Lyndsey Parker
14
As Heard On...
by Suzanne Baran
12
Better Living Through MP3
by Ken Micallef
148
Chart Watch
by Paul Grein
53
Framed
by John Kordosh
60
GetBack
by Shawn Amos
84
Hip-Hop Media Training
by Billy Johnson, Jr.
52
List Of The Day
by Rob O'Connor
237
Maximum Performance
by Lyndsey Parker
81
New This Week
by Dave DiMartino
64
On the Road With JamBase
by Aaron Kayce
24
Reality Rocks
by Lyndsey Parker
260
Rock's Backpages
by Mitchell Cohen (1976)
77
Rolling Stone Song Of The Day
by Chuck Eddy
70
Stop The Presses!
by Billy Altman
19
That's Really Week
by Dave DiMartino
67
The ARTHUR Blog
by Jay Babcock
41
The Blender Burner
by Blender Magazine
5
The Lefsetz Letter
by Bob Lefsetz
211
The MOJO Blog
by Stevie Chick
41
The NME Blog
by Dan Martin
22
The Spin Blog
by David Marchese
26
The URB Blog
by Brandon Perkins
9
The Y! Music Playlist Blog
by Robert of the Radish
298
Video Ga Ga
by Lyndsey Parker
40

Music Blog Archives

October 2008 (2)
September 2008 (5)
August 2008 (6)
July 2008 (5)
June 2008 (4)
May 2008 (4)
April 2008 (5)
March 2008 (4)
February 2008 (4)
January 2008 (5)
December 2007 (4)
November 2007 (5)
A rejuvenated Maxwell returns after 7-year break
AP
Tue Oct 7, 2008 3:00pm PDT
AP - It's hardly unusual for a singer to drop off the musical map. Declining album sales, drug habits, legal woes and other dramas have landed a multitude of chart-toppers on the "Whatever Happened To ..."…
More »
More Music News
My Music


Create your very own radio station based on your music tastes.